Through Thanksgiving and Christmas this year, Pillar Point Harbor's commercial crab fleet will stay at the dock. On October 30, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife delayed the commercial Dungeness season from the Oregon border to Point Conception until at least January 1, 2027. Recreational crabbing opened on November 7 with crab traps banned. CDFW said the restriction does not affect the use of hoop nets and crab snares.
So if Dungeness from our own water ends up on a Coastside holiday table before New Year's, someone pulled it up with a hoop net or a snare. They did it from the harbor's public fishing pier, from a jetty, or from the deck of a party boat that leaves from Johnson Pier.
The boats are tied up for a seventh year
The San Mateo Daily Journal reports that this is the seventh straight year the commercial season has been held past the holidays. The paper describes holiday crab as a long-standing staple on Thanksgiving and Christmas tables, and says the season "was once a profitable time" for selling it.
The reason is whales. CDFW tied the delay to the number of humpback whale entanglements in 2026 and to the high number of humpbacks across the fishing grounds. Current regulations require the director to act on those numbers for the rest of the year, and the delay also gives whales time to migrate out of California waters before commercial gear goes in.
People at the harbor saw this coming. Speaking to the Daily Journal, San Mateo County Harbor District manager Jim Pruett said:
"I can't say that we're surprised. There's a lot of whales out there. Anybody can see them, just driving down Highway 1."
In the same article, fisher Tim Obert, who sits on several state and regional fishing advisory boards, called the closure unsurprising to anyone who had been watching the entanglement numbers.
The whale rule and crab gear
The whale rule targets one kind of gear. Traps sit on the bottom for long stretches with lines running up to the surface. CDFW's restriction covers recreational crab traps in Fishing Zones 1 through 5 until at least January 1, and it states that the restriction "does not affect the use of hoop nets and crab snares."
Hoop nets come with their own rule. In the October 30 announcement, CDFW reminds crabbers that every hoop net has to be serviced every two hours and can't be left unattended longer than that. A fleet advisory also asks recreational crabbers not to set any gear where whales are present.
The other trouble spot on the state map is far from here. A separate domoic acid closure keeps recreational crabbing shut between Cape Mendocino and the Ten Mile State Marine Reserve, well north of the San Mateo County coast.
Where local Dungeness can come from before January
That leaves three sources close to the harbor. Here is how they compare.
| Where | What CDFW or the operator says | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Pillar Point Harbor Fishing Pier | On CDFW's list of public piers for San Mateo County | Seasons, size limits and bag limits still apply |
| Halfmoon Bay Jetty East and Halfmoon Bay Jetty West | Also on CDFW's San Mateo County public pier list | CDFW notes a landowner can close a structure for safety or maintenance at any time |
| Queen of Hearts, booked through Half Moon Bay Sportfishing & Tackle at 27 Johnson Pier | Rockfish and Dungeness combo trips through November, plus a crab-only day | Limit of 10 crab per person; trips are weather-dependent |
On CDFW's beach fishing page, the agency caps each person at two rods, lines, nets or crab appliances on a public pier.
A familiar name on that county list is marked closed. CDFW still shows the Pacifica Pier as "Currently Closed," for the reasons covered in our post on why the Pacifica Pier has no reopening date. That makes the Pillar Point pier and the Half Moon Bay jetties the nearest public spots on the county list without a closure note.
Gear and licenses are a short walk from the docks. Half Moon Bay Sportfishing & Tackle at 27 Johnson Pier sells day and annual fishing licenses along with bait and tackle. If you park near the harbor on a weekend, our post on Surfers Beach parking covers the changes along that stretch of Highway 1.
The Wednesday before Thanksgiving
For anyone hoping to serve local crab on Thanksgiving, the Queen of Hearts schedule has one date that matters most. On Wednesday, November 25, the boat runs a Dungeness Crab ONLY trip with no fishing. It leaves at 7:00 a.m., returns at 2:00 p.m., and costs $195 cash with a limit of 10 crab per person. On Thanksgiving Day the schedule says "Day off - Happy Thanksgiving!"
The rest of the schedule is combo trips. They run 6:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. through the end of November at $250 cash, with a limit of 10 crab plus 10 rockfish per person. Three December combos are listed:
- Friday, December 4
- Saturday, December 5
- Sunday, December 13
The last of those comes just before the state's mid-December decision. The boat is off on Christmas Day.
Plan around the weather too. The November schedule marked one mid-month trip as cancelled because of the ocean weather forecast and put several more days on hold. A November date on the calendar doesn't guarantee a trip, so book with some flexibility, especially for the 25th.
What decides whether the boats are back around New Year's
CDFW expects its next risk assessment in mid-December, and its Whale Safe Fisheries page lists the window as December 15 through 18. At that point the director will decide whether the commercial fishery can open and whether the recreational trap restriction can be lifted, using all available data, including a recommendation from the Dungeness Crab Fishing Gear Working Group.
Last season shows how much January 1 can stretch. For 2025-26, CDFW opened commercial fishing in Zones 3 through 5 on January 5, 2026, with a 40% reduction in gear. "At least January 1" sets the earliest possible date. It doesn't promise crab at the docks on New Year's Day, and whatever comes out of the December assessment sets the real opener.
When boats do return, the Harbor District's fish information page points buyers to its Fish Line at 726-8724 for current availability. Until then, the CDFW release on the recreational opener and commercial delay is the official source on gear and seasons. Local outlets such as Coastside Buzz reprinted the October release in full.
I'm sharing the crab rules here as general information, not legal advice. Check CDFW's current regulations, or ask the tackle shop, before you drop a net.
At Real Estate by Shanti, I follow what happens at Pillar Point Harbor because it shapes the whole Coastside winter, from the boats at Johnson Pier to the traffic on Highway 1. If you're curious how life around the harbor shows up in what your Half Moon Bay home is worth, request a free home valuation and I'll walk you through it.